Tuesday, November 4th, 2008

Going back to the basics

Filed under: Academia/Research — Daniel Lemire @ 18:19

Quick! Which type of program had its enrolment grow by 54 percent between 2000 and 2004?


Philosophy is the answer
according to an article pointed to us by Stephen Downes. This is quite simply a consequence of a phenomenon described by Paul Graham in some of his famous essays: while the best businessman or engineers work their craft in industry, the best philosophers and mathematicians reside at your nearby university.

My experience dealing with professors from business schools has been that they are not very impressive, on average. I would not trust most of them with my business. Would they make good entrepreneurs or CEOs?

However, your average Mathematics or Philosophy professor can dazzle you with his insights. While they may be out of touch and irrelevant to our universe, at least, they can teach something.

To quote Serge Dubuc, my thesis cosupervisor:

You can do great things with Mathematics, as long as you do something else.

In short, starting with Mathematics and then moving on to applications is a wise path.

I do not want to sound too negative or too critical, but at my school, 40 percent of all students attend the Business School. While some of my business colleagues there are extremely bright (especially the operational research types), I think it is not a good omen.

I am glad more fundamental programs, like philosophy are doing well.

1 Comment »

  1. My PhD is in philosophy. My main interests were logic, philosophy of mind, and philosophy of science. I eventually left philosophy, mainly, I think, because I put more faith in experimentation than in argument. However, I enjoyed my study of philosophy, and there is much to recommend about it. I admire the audacity with which philosophers tackle apparently intractable problems. It makes other fields seem narrow-minded, mundane, cautious, and inhibited.

    Comment by Peter Turney — 4/11/2008 @ 19:22

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

Warning: When entering a long comment, please ensure that you make copy of your text prior to submitting it. If the server should fail or if you hit a bug, you might lose your work. I am not responsible for your lost effort.

To spammers: I carefully review every single post and make sure that spam gets deleted. You are wasting your time if you are manually entering spam using this form. Read my terms of use to see what I consider to be abusive.

Example: two plus seven is '9'.

« Blog's main page

20 queries. 1.063 seconds. Valid XHTML

Powered by WordPress

Subscribe to this blog in a reader or by Email.